Has austerity gone too far?

Moderator:  Giancarlo Corsetti

  • Giancarlo Corsetti, 02 April 2012

    Is austerity self-defeating? Is it keeping Europeans underemployed for years and destroying the very growth needed to pay off the debt? Or is it steering nations clear of Greek-like tragedies? So starts a new debate on Vox on austerity, introduced in this column.

  • Alberto Alesina, Francesco Giavazzi, 03 April 2012

    Europe’s embrace of austerity has sparked a debate among economists. This column argues that the debate has gone astray. Until the critical principle – ‘how’ is as important as ‘how much’ – is embraced, the austerity debate in Europe will continue to be completely out of line with the real economic trade-offs.

  • J. Bradford DeLong, 06 April 2012

    The Vox debate on austerity rages on. Here Brad DeLong draws on his recent research with Larry Summers to argue that unless long-term real borrowing costs in the Eurozone exceed 5%, the short-term contractionary effects of spending cuts are likely to erode rather than bolster the overall fiscal situation.

  • Manfred J M Neumann, 17 April 2012

    Debt finance of public consumption has clearly gone too far in several countries, reaching the borderline of sustainability. Have austerity measures now gone too far as well? This column argues it seems too early to sound the alarm. First, the global economy is likely to grow by 3.3 % this year, and second, reversing the fiscal stance or exiting the euro are worse options than austerity.

  • Carlo Cottarelli, 20 April 2012

    As with austerity itself, the austerity debate shows no sign of disappearing any time soon. This column argues that the last thing that the world economy needs at this uncertain moment is a knee-jerk reaction from fiscal policy. While the column agrees that governments need to make cuts, it stresses they should not lose sight of the bigger picture.

  • Marco Buti, Lucio R Pench, 20 April 2012

    Most economists agree that European economies share the need to reduce public deficits and debts. This column stresses that while gradual consolidations are in general more likely to succeed than cold-shower ones, the superiority of a gradual strategy tends to evaporate for high levels of debt and is also less pronounced for consolidation episodes following a financial crisis.

  • John Van Reenen, 27 April 2012

    Many policymakers in Europe seem to stick to the idea that fiscal consolidation might inspire confidence and help the economy to grow. This column argues these sentiments may be understandable but are basically wrong. For countries like the UK where borrowing is relatively cheap and sovereign default unlikely, slowing down the pace of fiscal consolidation would be a rational response. The obsession over the fiscal stance is a distraction from sustainable long-run growth.

Latest Debate Commentaries

  • Let’s take a risk (Secular Stagnation)

    Vox Website Administrator, VoxEU.org, 27 February 2015

    The last time we got out of a depression like we experience at this juncture, we made enormous investments. Enormous investments  in research and development. Inventions were made like radar, the first computers to crack codes, the first rockets, the first jet engine, the nuclear bomb (nuclear energy), new medicines like penicillin. Major innovations that were the building blocks for major...
  • Biagio Bossone, The Group of Lecce, Chairman, 06 February 2015

    Secular stagnation in the Eurozone?1With inflation declining and constantly undershooting forecasts, and the economies gripped by fiscal austerity, zero-lower bounded interest rates, and gloomy expectations, the Eurozone may have found itself caught into what Caballero and Fahri (2103) call a ‘safety trap’, i.e., an excess demand for safe assets (money and government bonds). Essentially, agents...
  • Fractional reserve banking (FRB): Looking back, looking forward (Banking reform: Do we know what has to be done?)

    , , 27 January 2015

    The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has relaxed certain banking norms, following the announcement in the Union Budget 2014-15 to ease availability of finance for infrastructure. As per its circular of 15.07.2014, banks can issue rupee denominated plain vanilla unsecured, uninsured bonds of minimum 7 years tenure to finance infrastructure and affordable housing. Incremental funds deployed by banks to...
  • Growth and jobs in Europe: Which way now? (Has austerity gone too far?)

    Anis Chowdhury, United Nations ESCAP, 20 November 2014

    Anis Chowdhury (United Nations Economic and Social Commissions for Asia and the Pacific) and Iyanatul Islam (International Labour Organization).Whether it is EU28 or EA18, the European region has suffered two to three years of negative growth between 2008 and 2014. The projected recovery in 2015 is well below the rate of growth that is expected to be achieved by other advanced economies.1 Some...
  • Anis Chowdhury, United Nations ESCAP, 26 September 2014

    On 9 September, 2014, a large majority of member States mandated the UN to create a “multilateral legal framework for sovereign debt restructuring”. The resolution (A/68/L.57/Rev2) commits the General Assembly to agree on modalities, or the terms and logistics, for commencing open, intergovernmental negotiations on a sovereign debt restructuring framework by the end of 2014.  Subsequently, the...
  • Anis Chowdhury, United Nations ESCAP, 18 June 2014

    Iyanatul Islam, Chief, Employment and Labour Market Policies Branch, Employment Policy Department, ILO, Geneva Anis Chowdhury, Director, Macroeconomic Policy and Development Division, UN-ESCAP Introduction The traditional discourse in development economics focussed on issues of underemployment, poverty and structural transformation. However, these issues receded into the background with the...
  • Anis Chowdhury, United Nations ESCAP, 21 January 2014

    By Iyanatul Islam (ILO) and Anis Chowdhury (UN-ESCAP)1,2 Conventional macroeconomics as applied to developing economies is part of an overall framework that has a rather narrow conceptualization of economic stability based on certain thresholds: low, single digit inflation (usually less than 5%), fiscal deficits of less than 3% of GDP, debt to GDP ratio of 40% or less, and foreign exchange...
  • Dr Mark Fernando, Humanitarian Healthcare, 30 August 2013

      This Advisory Paper is intended to assist in securing economic stability, whilst ensuring that humanitarian interventions can have the very strongest possible impact and are effective, combined with an Economics and Diplomacy Model that can provide for a regionally and internationally acceptable mechanism that can ensure peacemaking is successful in the context of enabling public security to be...
  • Dr Mark Fernando, Humanitarian Healthcare, 30 August 2013

      This Advisory Paper is intended to assist in securing economic stability, whilst ensuring that humanitarian interventions can have the very strongest possible impact and are effective, combined with an Economics and Diplomacy Model that can provide for a regionally and internationally acceptable mechanism that can ensure peacemaking is successful in the context of enabling public security to be...
  • Dr Mark Fernando, Humanitarian Healthcare, 30 August 2013

      This Advisory Paper is intended to assist in securing economic stability, whilst ensuring that humanitarian interventions can have the very strongest possible impact and are effective, combined with an Economics and Diplomacy Model that can provide for a regionally and internationally acceptable mechanism that can ensure peacemaking is successful in the context of enabling public security to be...